Income Protection Insurance vs Mortgage Protection
Both mortgage insurance and income protection can cover home payments. But the latter can pay for other bills too.
Income protection and mortgage protection insurance are two different types of income replacement. Both can pay you if you need to take some time off work because of an injury or illness. However, mortgage protection can only be used to pay your mortgage repayments, while income protection can be used to cover other everyday living expenses as well.
What is the difference between income protection and mortgage protection?
The main difference between income protection and mortgage protection is this:
- Mortgage protection. Can only be used for your mortgage repayments.
- Income protection. Can be used for mortgage repayments and other living expenses, including credit card debt, school fees, electricity bills and food.
We've highlighted some other key differences below.
| Key Differences | Mortgage Protection Insurance | Income Protection Insurance |
|---|---|---|
| How does it pay out? | In one lump-sum or ongoing benefit payment | In monthly instalments, like an income. |
| When does it pay out? | If you pass away or become injured or ill | If you become sick or injured and can't work |
| How much does it pay out? | A specified amount to cover your mortgage repayments | Up to 75% of your income |
| What can it pay for? | Your mortgage repayments | Anything you want, including mortgage repayments |
| How long can you receive payments for? | It depends on the size of your loan and the agreement you make with the insurer | It depends on the 'benefit period' you choose. Options are generally 2, 3 or 5 years, or up until a certain age e.g. 65 |
| Are the premiums tax deductible? | No, premiums are generally not tax deductible for mortgage protection insurance. | Yes, premiums are generally tax deductible for income insurance. |
| What's the application process like? | Mortgage protection doesn't usually require any blood or medical tests when you apply. | Income protection requires you to disclose lifestyle factors such as age, smoking status and pre-existing conditions, which will affect the cost of your cover. |
Compare income protection policies and get a quote
Our tables can't show you prices because your premiums are based on the type of job you have, your age, health and a few other factors. However, to help give you an idea of how price varies, we've outlined some costs below based on a few different occupations who all selected a $3,000 monthly benefit.
| Cost | Age | Gender | Smoker | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Graphic designer | $45 a month | 30 | Female | |
| Mechanic | $84 a month | 40 | Male | |
| Carpenter | $222 a month | 50 | Female | |
| Accountant | $149 a month | 60 | Male |
*Quotes are based on the average of three quotes from three different insurers. Each person is on a $3,000 monthly benefit with the benefit period as close to 1 year as possible. The waiting period was selected as near to 30 days as the insurer would allow.
What different scores mean
9+
Excellent
These products offer great value, with a good score across both features and price.
7+
Great
These are competitive products, though they didn't quite get top scores.
5+
Standard
These products might offer less value or command a higher premium than others in the market.
0+
Basic
These products might only offer a basic set of features or aren't very competitive on price.
1 - 5 of 7
Compare alternatives
We currently don't have a partnership for that product, but we have other similar offers to choose from (how we picked these ):
Finder Score - Income Protection
Income Protection is a little complicated and a lot overwhelming. That's why we made the Finder Score, to make it easier to compare Life Insurance products against each other. Our experts analysed over 12 products and gave each one a score between 1 and 10.
But a higher score doesn't always mean a product is better for you. Your situation is unique, so your policy choice will be too. Don't think of Finder Score as the final word, but as a good place to start your life insurance comparison.
Read full Finder Score methodology
Is it worth getting mortgage protection insurance?
If you have income protection, it probably isn't worth getting mortgage protection insurance as well. Both cover you if you have to take time off work due to an injury or illness. However, mortgage protection will only cover your mortgage repayments. It can't cover all the other bills you need to pay — but income protection can.
For instance, say your mortgage repayments account for 28% of your monthly income — the limit that many lenders recommend — that still leaves a significant amount of monthly expenses left to pay for if you're out of work.
Income protection insurance can't provide you with 100% of your income, but at 75%, it can make sure you're still able to pay for the majority of your monthly expenses, including:
- Mortgage repayments
- School fees
- Food
- Car insurance
- Fuel
- Utilities such as electricity
- Credit card payments
- Student loans
Can I have mortgage protection and income protection?
If you have both mortgage protection and income protection and submit a claim to your income insurer, it's likely they will reduce your monthly benefit based on your mortgage protection benefit. This is because income protection is capped at 75% of your income to prevent you from earning more while you're off than you would while you were working.
If you already have mortgage protection but want income protection to cover all your other monthly expenses, buy a policy that pays you a smaller percentage of your monthly income.
For example, if your mortgage accounts for 30% of your income, get an income protection policy that pays you 45% of your income, keeping you within the 75% limit. That way, you won't be wasting money.
What benefits are included with income protection and mortgage protection?
Standard built-in benefits
- Choice of agreed or indemnity value: Income protection gives you a choice between agreed value or indemnity protection. Agreed value guarantees your salary benefits at the time of your application, safeguarding against changes in your salary. Indemnity protection requires you to prove your salary if you make a claim. Agreed value benefits are up to 20% higher but are important for people with flexible incomes such as freelancers or small business owners.
- Death benefit: This benefit covers you in the event of death or terminal illness.
- Total and partial disability benefits: Most insurers include disability benefits in all income protection plans, but these differ between total and partial disability benefits. The definitions of total and partial disability differs between providers, but total disability generally stops you from working due to an illness or accident, whereas partial disability means you are able to work part time or in another occupation.
- Stepped or level premiums: You have a choice between stepped or level premiums. Level premiums remain the same throughout the life of your policy, whereas stepped premiums start off lower and increase with age.
Additional features at an extra cost
These options differ between insurance providers, but some of the main additional options for life insurance cover include:
- Superannuation contribution: Contributions to your super are continued while your are receiving an income benefit.
- Involuntary unemployment: Income protection does not offer a payout for redundancy, but some providers offer features such as loan repayment cover or premium waivers.
- Rehabilitation benefit: Your insurance provider will cover the cost incurred from rehabilitation that can help you if you become completely disabled
- Accommodation, overseas or domestic transport: This option safeguards you if you become disabled while away from home.
- Family support: This benefit in the event if you are totally disabled and an immediate family member must stop work to look after you.
- Return to work bonus: Some insurers offer this benefit when you return to work after being injured.
Standard built-in benefits with mortgage protection
- Death Cover: This benefit covers you in the event of death or terminal illness. Any difference between sum-insured and amount owing on mortgage can be paid to your estate.
- Disability benefits: You will receive a monthly benefit payment to cover your mortgage repayments in the event of an illness or injury and you are unable to work.
- Involuntary unemployment: Mortgage protection insurance will provide cover in the event of redundancy generally up to three months.
- Complimentary accidental death cover: Complimentary cover for accidental death while loan provider is setting up home loan. This is usually provided for up to 2 months.
Important points to know about a mortgage protection policy
There are a few other important points worth keeping mind when it comes to mortgage protection policies:
- You will generally not be covered for any claims related to an injury or illness that you received medical consultation for in the months before you purchased the policy.
- Involuntary unemployment cover is usually not available if you are employed in a permanent part time, casual, contract or temporary capacity for less than 20 hours per week or if you are a sole trader working less than 20 hours per week.
- Cover may only be available up to a maximum loan value.
More resources on Finder
More guides on Finder
-
ahm income protection review
With ahm income protection, you can over up to 70% of your income (up to $10,000 monthly) if you can't work after sickness or injury.
-
Cost of living comparison
How much could you save if you lived in a different city in Australia? Let's find out.
-
How to claim income protection
A guide to everything you need to know about income protection claims.
-
Sole trader income protection insurance
Income protection for sole traders provides financial support, via a monthly payment, if you’re unable to work due to illness or injury.
-
Is income protection insurance tax-deductible?
One of the benefits of income protection insurance is that you may have the ability to claim a tax deduction on your premium benefits. Find out if the same rules apply for policies inside super.
-
Redundancy and unemployment insurance
Most providers no longer offer unemployment insurance in Australia if you're made redundant.
-
NobleOak Disability Income Insurance Review
NobleOak has been offering personal insurance solutions direct to Australians for over 137 years. Discover the benefits and features available on the NobleOak Income Protection policy and make a secure enquiry for cover.
-
Insuranceline Income Protection Review
Looking to protect your income if you suffer a serious illness or disability? Insuranceline Income Protection can cover up to 75% of your income
-
BT Income Protection Insurance review
Interested in receiving a quote for BT Income Protection Insurance? Find out what is covered under each of the policies and make a secure enquiry for cover.
-
Best income protection Australia – a deep dive into 11 top providers
Looking for the best income protection insurance but not exactly sure where to start? Compare the Finder Awards 2023 insurance winners.