Dealer finance vs car loan – which is the smoothest road to a new car?

Don't drive around in circles trying to work out your best finance option, read everything you need to know here.

Key takeaways

  • Dealer finance is offered through car dealerships where you're buying the car, whereas car loans are through banks or non-bank lenders.
  • Dealer finance often comes with a balloon payment option, which can lower repayments but you'll need to fork out a lump sum at the end.
  • You can often get better deals and terms through a car loan, especially if the loan is secured against the vehicle, but you should always compare.

Car loans and dealer finance are both popular car financing options that can get you the funds you need, but there are some key differences and considerations to know of.

Let's take a look at them below.

How does financing a car work?

Financing refers to the funds you secure in order to buy a vehicle. You have a number of car finance options, such as using your existing savings, applying for a car loan or applying for dealer finance through a car dealership. Once you have secured finance, you will use the money to cover the purchase price of your new car. If you're getting a car on finance, you'll then need to repay the amount you borrowed according to the terms you agreed to with the lender.

What is car dealer finance?

Dealer finance refers to the finance options offered by a car dealership, such as Toyota Finance, Nissan Finance or Esanda, which secures the funds through a lender.

If you choose to get dealer finance, your car payment plan will be similar to a normal car loan and require you to make regular repayments over a set period to cover the cost of the vehicle. Unlike most car loans, many dealer finance options give you the ability to lower your regular repayments by making a lump-sum balloon payment at the end of the loan term.

Dealer finance may offer lower rates than car loans, but these rates may only be available on specific makes and models. New regulations introduced in 2018 mean that the dealer can no longer increase the interest rate secured with the lender when offering finance to a buyer.

What is a car loan?

With a car loan, you receive a lump-sum payment to purchase your vehicle and then you pay back the money plus interest over a set period.

You can use your vehicle as security against the loan, so you can get more competitive rates than unsecured loans, which can be anywhere from 4-15% p.a. However, if you default on your loan, you can lose your vehicle. Car loan terms are usually for between 1 and 7 years and rates can be fixed or variable.

Dealer finance vs car loan comparison

Dealer financeCar loan
Interest rates
  • May offer lower interest rates than car loans
  • Low interest rates may only be available for specific makes and models
  • Commission for the car salesman may push rates up
  • 0% rate deals may indicate a higher purchase price for the car
  • Lenders offer various rates, which means you can choose the most competitive
  • Using your car as security lets you take advantage of lower rates
Loan term
  • Typically 3- to 4-year terms
  • A balloon payment is usually payable at the end of the term
  • Early repayment costs may apply
Benefits
  • The dealer finance rep handles the paperwork
  • No need to shop around for better offers
  • Balloon payment can help lower your regular repayments
  • Gives you leverage to negotiate the sale price
  • A range of competitive car loans are available
  • Your repayments will see your car loan repaid in full at the end of the term
  • You can choose your lender and your loan
  • Loans are available for new, used and classic cars
Drawbacks
  • You need good credit to be eligible
  • It's usually only available to new vehicles
  • Balloon payments can be large and it can be difficult to save that money while repaying a loan
  • Higher interest rates may apply to certain types of loans
  • Upfront and ongoing fees may apply
Suitability
  • Borrowers that want to buy a new car and have a deposit saved
  • Borrowers that want to shop around and have the option of buying from a dealer or a private seller

What does a balloon payment mean?

A balloon payment is a lump sum payment at the end of your finance period to finish paying off the car. It's typically associated with dealer finance. Depending on your financial situation and preferences, opting for a balloon payment may help manage how you repay your loan.

For example, let's say you want to purchase a $40,000 car. With the option of a balloon payment you might agree to pay $5,000 at the end of your loan, meaning you make monthly repayments towards the remaining $35,000.

If at the end of your finance period you can't afford to pay the balloon payment, you may also choose to refinance your car loan. This is how many dealership finance companies make their money.

If you do decide to opt for dealer finance, calculate how much you will need to put away each month to have your balloon payment saved at the end of the loan term and then make sure you have it. This way, you will have your finance paid off and won't have to enter into another refinancing contract.

Example: Car loan vs dealer finance with balloon payment

How much can they save?

Neighbours, Julian and Susan, are both in need of a new car. After researching their options and choosing what kind of car they want to get, Julian opts for a car loan while Susan takes on financing from the dealership where she made her purchase.

The cars they purchased ended up being the same price – $50,000 – so who chose the better financing option?

Julian takes out a car loan at a 8.00% p.a. rate for 8 years. Using a car loan repayment calculator, he sees that he will pay $707 in monthly repayments and will pay a total of $17,857 in interest over the course of the loan term.

Susan, who takes on dealer finance with the same term and rate, sees that she'll have monthly repayments of $637. She'll be borrowing the same amount of money, but her residual balloon payment of $5,000 means she'll only be charged interest on $45,000.

The results

Julian continues to pay $707 every month and finishes repaying his loan after 8 years. His repayments total $67,857 for his original $50,000 vehicle purchase.

Susan makes her lower ongoing repayments of $637, but when it comes to the end of her 8-year loan term, she's responsible for paying $5,000.

She would save that $5,000 by putting away $52.08 each month, meaning in theory she contributes (directly or indirectly) about $689 a month towards the car.

This totals $66,144 over the life of the loan, saving $1,713 when compared to Julian.

* This is a fictional, but realistic, example.

How to compare car financing options

The decision between car loans or dealer finance really comes down to your own personal financial situation and what's on offer to you at the time.

Some things to consider when comparing include:

  • Is there the option of repaying the loan early?
  • Can they make extra repayments?
  • Do they have access to features such as a redraw facility?
  • Do they have special benefits like discounted insurance?

Although it might seem convenient to take out dealer finance when you are there at the dealership, convenience can come with a price. Before settling with what you're being offered, compare outside banks and non-bank lenders to see what terms and rates are being offered elsewhere.

Always compare the rates and terms offered by a variety of different lenders before committing to anyone. There are numerous tools available to help you with this, such as comparison charts and car loan repayment calculators.

As with any loan product, if you want to buy a car on finance, you should make sure that it is within your budget and that you will be able to meet your repayments.

See your chance of approval with the Finder app

Worried about getting knocked back when applying for a personal loan? Use the Finder app to estimate your chance of approval and apply with greater confidence. Pop in your phone number below to get your download link.

Frequently asked questions about dealer finance vs car loan

To make sure you get accurate and helpful information, this guide has been edited by David Gregory as part of our fact-checking process.
Rebecca Pike's headshot
Written by

Senior writer

Rebecca Pike is Finder's senior writer for money. She joined Finder after almost four years writing for business publications in the mortgage and finance industry, including three years as editor of Mortgage Professional Australia. She regularly appears as a money expert on programs like Sunrise and Today, as well as across radio and newspapers. She also holds ASIC-recognised certifications in Tier 1 Generic Knowledge and Tier 2 General Advice Deposit Products. See full bio

Rebecca's expertise
Rebecca has written 201 Finder guides across topics including:
  • Home loans
  • Cost of living
  • Budgeting

More guides on Finder

  • Australian Mutual Bank Car Loan

    Borrow up to 100% of the purchase price up to $100k and access a free redraw feature for any extra repayments you make.

  • Car loans for classic cars

    Want to buy a classic car but don't have the ready money? There are still financing options available for classic vehicles. Find out what loans you have to choose one and which one will work best for you.

  • Rent an Uber car in the Gold Coast

    There's a way you can drive with Uber without using your own car – find out how.

  • Rent a car for Uber in Canberra

    Find out how you could rent a car to drive with Uber in Canberra

  • Tesla Superchargers Map: Where you can charge in Australia

    Find out the extent of Australia's Tesla Supercharger network with our complete map of every charging station.

  • Should I refinance or pay my novated lease balloon payment?

    If you've come to the end of your novated lease and you are left with a balloon payment, you might be wondering whether to refinance that into a personal loan or take on another novated lease.

  • Compare boat loans

    If you've been wanting a boat but didn't know where to start, read up a range of boat loans you can apply for. Secured and unsecured options are available and you could have the funds the next business day.

  • Best car loans – 4 expert picks

    The best car loan isn't necessarily the one with the lowest rate. Learn how to spot the best car loans and compare 15+ car loan products with Finder.

  • Used car loans comparison

    You can still get a car loan if you want to finance a used car. Find out how you can get a used car loan and see what rates are available for the used car you want. Learn how to best compare lenders and apply for your loan today.

  • Compare pre-approved car loan options

    Finding the right car loan shouldn't be as hard as finding the right car. Get a loan that will give you pre-approval so you can go shopping with the right amount of funds.

Ask a question

You are about to post a question on finder.com.au:

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com.au is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder only provides general advice and factual information, so consider your own circumstances, or seek advice before you decide to act on our content. By submitting a question, you're accepting our Terms Of Service and Finder Group Privacy & Cookies Policy.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

4 Responses

    Default Gravatar
    RanaJuly 10, 2016

    Hi , can you tell me options to get out of dealer finance once signed. I have put in $10 k for a deposit on new car and found s new one $23990 drive away. I sighed the contract and the finance after asking whether I could pay it off early without penalty as when I sell my current car I’d like to put it back on the loan and pay the rest off within 12-18mths. Looking at the contract three days ago I have noticed it is a secured fixed loan and has an exit admin fee, a $15 penalty per month fee for the rest of the 5 years , and a break fee determined by the finance company to recoup their interest losses for me paying it out early !!! The dealer finance guy definitely did not explain those fees !!!! So now the car has arrived at the dealers it’s been paid for but I have not made a finance payment yet to the bank. When I rang them they told me I could perhaps “flat cancel” ?

      AvatarFinder
      ElizabethJuly 11, 2016Finder

      Hi Rana,

      There are cooling off periods for vehicle finance deals but they vary in each state and the maximum is only three days, so this may have lapsed for you. If the financier did not tell you about the extra charges you can complain to them and tell them you were not aware of the charges in the contract. You can also seek independent advice from the credit and investments ombudsmen to see what kind of options you have available to you.

      I hope this helps,

      Elizabeth

    Default Gravatar
    RussellAugust 20, 2015

    should I have to take out no gap insurance and consumer credit insurance for a dealer loan on a new car, also is it right they charge a dealer agency fee and a loan set up fee, finally 7.49 fixed doesn’t seem competitive and why should i agree to pay commission on consumer credit insurance

      AvatarFinder
      ElizabethAugust 21, 2015Finder

      Hi Russell,

      Thanks for your question.

      For insurance, these are generally optional extras and its up to you whether you want to take them on. It’s best to review what the insurance offers and when you will and won’t be covered, what limitations there are, etc. before agreeing to take it out. Dealer agency fees and commissions are quite common with dealer financing as this is how the finance company makes money – you can ask exactly how much commission they are making and how it is calculated on your finance amount to see how much it adds to your loan. For the amount being competitive, you might want to compare it with other offers out there to see if you are getting a good deal.

      I hope this information has been of use.

      Thanks,

      Elizabeth

Go to site
Compare your car loan options in seconds